The Obsession With Commissions in the Medicare Industry
When independent Medicare agents evaluate FMOs, the first question is often about commission levels. It’s understandable. Commissions are easy to compare, easy to market, and easy to assume they are the key to higher income. Unfortunately, this mindset causes many agents to overlook what actually determines long-term success.
Higher commissions may increase income per sale, but they do not fix operational problems, prevent compliance mistakes, or create efficient workflows. Over time, agents often discover that a lack of support costs far more than any commission increase ever pays.
Why Commissions Alone Do Not Build Sustainable Careers
A Medicare career is not built on isolated transactions. It is built on consistency, retention, compliance, and long-term client relationships. Without proper guidance, agents frequently experience:
- Confusion around carrier rules and enrollment procedures
- Delays when issues arise
- Missed opportunities due to poor follow-up
- Increased stress during peak seasons like AEP
None of these challenges are solved by higher commissions. They are solved by support, structure, and clarity.
What an Agent Success Manager Actually Does
An Agent Success Manager (ASM) is fundamentally different from a recruiter or generic support representative. Their role is proactive, not reactive. A strong ASM works closely with agents to help them operate efficiently and confidently.
An Agent Success Manager typically supports agents by:
- Answering operational and compliance questions clearly and promptly
- Assisting with carrier escalations and enrollment issues
- Helping agents set up workflows and processes
- Providing guidance on time management and prioritization
- Supporting preparation for AEP and other critical periods
This ongoing support prevents small issues from becoming major disruptions.
The Hidden Cost of “High Commission, Low Support” Environments
Agents working without structured support often spend hours trying to solve problems on their own. This includes searching for answers, waiting for carrier responses, or fixing avoidable mistakes. Over time, this leads to:
- Lost productivity
- Increased compliance risk
- Lower client satisfaction
- Burnout and frustration
When these costs are added up, they far exceed the value of a slightly higher commission rate.
Support Creates Scalability and Confidence
Agents who receive consistent guidance are better positioned to scale their business. With the help of an Agent Success Manager, agents can:
- Build repeatable systems
- Improve client retention
- Prepare strategically for AEP
- Make informed business decisions
- Grow without unnecessary stress
Support creates stability, and stability enables growth.
Long-Term Thinking Beats Short-Term Gains
Agents who succeed year after year tend to prioritize environments that support long-term development. An Agent Success Manager becomes a strategic partner who understands the agent’s goals, challenges, and business model.
In contrast, agents who chase the highest commission often find themselves switching FMOs frequently, rebuilding processes, and losing momentum.
Conclusion
Commissions matter, but they do not define success. Guidance, structure, and proactive support are what allow agents to build sustainable, scalable Medicare careers. In the long run, an Agent Success Manager consistently delivers more value than higher commission levels alone.
English