The 2027 Medicare Star Ratings, released October 8, 2026, are one input in your AEP appointments, not the recommendation. Use them to flag in-force clients whose contract rating changed, schedule review calls, and explain quality clearly. Networks, drugs, costs, and fit still come first. Follow MCMG disclosure rules, avoid “best plan” claims, and document every review.
Here’s the thing. Every October, the new ratings come out and a few clients call asking if they’re “in a bad plan now.” You’ll get better results if you’ve decided how to handle that before AEP opens on October 15, not while you’re on the phone.
What do the 2027 Star Ratings actually show?
Fewer contracts earned top ratings this year, but more people are enrolled in highly rated contracts. Five-star contracts fell, the share of contracts at 4 stars or higher dropped, and the national average barely moved. For most of your book, the change will be small.
Here are the numbers in plain terms. Medical Daily reports that 508 Medicare Advantage contracts with drug coverage (MA-PD) were rated for 2027, down from 516. Five-star contracts fell from 22 to 15, and “only six of this year’s 15 five-star contracts also held five stars last year.”
The 4-star picture looks different depending on whether you count contracts or people. According to HFMA, “only 37% of 508 Medicare Advantage Prescription Drug (MA-PD) contracts received four or more stars, down from 44.4% in 2026.” But the share of enrollees in 4-star-plus contracts rose from 67% to nearly 71%, and the enrollment-weighted average slipped only slightly, from 4.01 to 3.99.
A few more data points to know:
- Standalone drug plans (PDPs): 41 were rated and none earned five stars. About 22% of PDP enrollees are now in plans rated 4 stars or higher, up from about 2%, per Medical Daily.
- Low-performing icon: Four MA contracts carry it for 2027, meaning they’ve been rated below 3 stars three years in a row.
- Low-rated contracts: Becker’s Payer Issues reports 32 contracts at 2.5 stars or lower, up from 23, with more than 285,000 enrollees combined. Low-rated contracts show up in Texas markets too.
- Why carriers care: Becker’s notes the ratings “will determine quality bonus payments for 2028.” That’s funding for future years, not this year’s benefits.
This is all happening in a tighter market. CMS projects the weighted average MA premium will drop from $14.37 to $12.00 and says “approximately eight in 10 MA beneficiaries will be able to remain in their current plan with the same or a lower premium in 2027,” according to the CMS press release. Choice is shrinking, though. MarketWatch, citing KFF, reports the average beneficiary can choose from 35 plans in 2027 versus 39 in 2026, and 181 counties will have no MA plans, up from 67.
Should a star drop change my client’s plan?
Not automatically. A star change tells you to review the client. It doesn’t tell you to move them. Doctors, drugs, pharmacies, and total costs decide whether the plan still fits.
Let me show you what I mean. Say a client’s contract dropped from 4 stars to 3.5. Their cardiologist is still in network, their three maintenance drugs are still covered at tiers they can afford, and their costs for 2027 look about the same. Moving that client because of half a star could put them in a plan that misses a doctor or a drug. That’s a worse outcome, not a better one.
Now flip it. Same half-star drop, but the Annual Notice of Change (ANOC) shows a drug moved tiers and a key specialist left the network. The plan may no longer fit. In that case the rating didn’t cause the problem. It just gave you a reason to look.
Keep the order straight in every review:
- Doctors and network
- Prescriptions and pharmacies
- Total expected costs for the year
- The client’s stated priorities
- Star rating as supporting context
How do I explain star ratings to clients without overpromising?
Tell clients the ratings are Medicare’s yearly score for a contract’s quality and service, on a 1-to-5 scale. Be clear about what they don’t measure. A star rating doesn’t tell anyone whether their doctors are in network, whether their drugs are covered, or what they’ll pay.
Something like this works:
“Medicare rates plans every year on things like member experience, customer service, and preventive care. It’s useful information, and I’ll show you where your plan landed. But the rating doesn’t tell us whether your doctors or medications are covered, so we’ll check those first.”
A few things to avoid saying:
- That a higher-rated plan will save them money or cover more.
- That a lower rating means the plan is “bad” or “in trouble.”
- That stars predict next year’s benefits.
Also remember that ratings apply to a contract, which can include many plans across different counties. Two plans under the same contract share a rating even if their networks and costs are very different.
What compliance rules apply when I mention star ratings?
When you reference star ratings in any marketing, follow the Medicare Communications and Marketing Guidelines (MCMG) star-rating disclosure requirements and use carrier-approved materials. Reference the correct contract year, don’t present one measure as the overall rating, and never call a plan the “best.”
In practice, that means:
- Use the rating for the right year. Once 2027 ratings are out, label them clearly as 2027 Star Ratings. Don’t mix last year’s ratings with this year’s.
- Use approved materials. Carriers publish standardized star-rating documents and disclaimers. Use those instead of building your own graphic.
- No superlatives or rankings. “Highest-rated plan in your area” or “best plan” language creates risk. Stick to the factual rating.
- Don’t lead with stars in outreach. Ratings belong inside a needs-based conversation with a proper Scope of Appointment (SOA), not in a cold pitch.
- Ask when you’re unsure. If a carrier’s rules and your marketing idea don’t line up, check with the carrier or your upline before anything goes out.
How do I use the five-star SEP after AEP?
The five-star Special Enrollment Period (SEP) lets a client switch into a five-star plan in their area once between December 8 and November 30 of the following year. That makes it a year-round review tool after AEP ends. It only works where a five-star plan is actually offered.
Medicare.gov states, “You can use this Special Enrollment Period only once between December 8 and November 30 the following year.” It also adds two cautions worth repeating to clients:
- Moving from an MA plan with drug coverage to a five-star MA plan without drug coverage “may” mean losing prescription coverage, with a possible Part D late enrollment penalty.
- Moving from an MA-PD to a standalone drug plan returns the client to Original Medicare for health coverage.
With 15 five-star MA-PD contracts and no five-star standalone PDPs this year, most of your clients won’t have a five-star option nearby. Check before you bring it up. When one is available, run the same needs analysis you’d run in AEP. Five stars doesn’t make a plan the right fit on its own.
What should I do for clients in low-rated or low-performing plans?
Reach out calmly, review their needs, and let them decide. Clients in a plan with the low-performing icon can switch any time they’re in that plan. The goal is an informed decision, not a scare.
Medicare.gov lists that option for people in a plan “that’s had a star rating of less than 3 stars for the last 3 years,” available “any time you’re in the low-performing plan.” There’s one operational wrinkle. Per Medical Daily, people can’t enroll online in a low-performing plan through Plan Finder and must call the plan or 1-800-MEDICARE.
For outreach to these clients:
- Lead with service: “The new ratings came out and I want to review your coverage with you.”
- Don’t call their plan bad or tell them they have to leave.
- Run the full review. Some clients in low-rated plans have a doctor or drug setup they don’t want to give up.
- Document what you reviewed, what options you showed, and what they chose.
What’s my AEP-week star ratings workflow?
Pull the ratings for every contract in your book, flag the clients whose contract changed, prioritize review calls, and document each one. It’s a simple routine, and it keeps the ratings in their place: a reason to check in, not a reason to churn.
Here’s a workflow you can run this week:
- Look up ratings. Use Medicare Plan Finder for client-facing views and the CMS Star Ratings data files to see your whole book by contract number.
- Match contracts to clients. List each in-force client’s contract ID with the 2026 and 2027 overall rating.
- Tag the changes. In our free Medicare CRM, OmniReach, you can tag each client by contract star change (up, down, unchanged, low-performing icon) and build a call list from the tags.
- Prioritize calls. Start with low-performing icon contracts, then contracts at 2.5 stars or lower, then any drops of half a star or more.
- Review needs first. Pair the rating with the ANOC: network, drugs, pharmacies, and costs.
- Document every call. Record the SOA, what you reviewed, the options shown, and the client’s decision, including “stayed put.”
- Set a December 8 reminder. For clients near a five-star plan, note it for a post-AEP review using the five-star SEP.
We talk through this kind of book review often on the Podcast Medicare Agent IQ, because it’s one of the steadiest ways to protect retention without overreacting to a headline.
If you want a clean way to flag every client whose plan rating changed and a documented review workflow for AEP, that’s the kind of system TMS builds with independent agents. TMS Correduría de Seguros is a Texas-based FMO with statewide reach.